Friday, April 26, 2019

More tornadoes and more deaths in Texas and Louisiana, April 24 and 25, 2019


Yet another tornado episode occurred in the South on Wednesday, April 24 and Thursday, April 25 in Texas (TX) and Louisiana (LA), adding 2 deaths to 2019's tornado toll during the early morning hours of April 25 .

The tornado pictured above near College Station, TX at mid-afternoon on Wednesday didn't kill anyone, but was rated EF2 and was widely photographed.  This tornado is interesting because it formed rapidly from a small cell that was not very impressive on radar (see images below).  As a result of being small and relatively distant from radar sites, there was no tornado warning at the time.


Here's the setting at 4:00 pm CDT... A surface low was just west of College Station (CLL), with a stationary east-west outflow boundary (from earlier storms to the north) also located near CLL.  The circled "S" shows the location of the small supercell that produced the tornado as it crossed this boundary going from south to north:
Why did the storm produce a tornado so quickly?  It probably had something to do with the boundary; remember from other posts I've made this year that tornadoes definitely seem to favor boundaries.  This is suggested by the SPC mesoanalysis images below at 4:00 pm CDT:
Notice in the 2nd graphic above (SRH, or storm-relative helicity) how there was a band of enhanced low-level wind shear along and north of the outflow boundary, likely promoting low-level storm rotation in that area.  This same area overlapped low-level CAPE (surface-based instability that can promote rapid vertical stretching) along and south of the boundary, likely making a very favorable environment for a tornado as the cell crossed the boundary in a narrow corridor before it encountered cooler air farther north.

There's not room to show it here, but the RAP model 1-hour forecast sounding at 4:00 pm for CLL had 1200-1300 J/kg of total MLCAPE, over 300 m2/s2 of 0-1 km SRH (a nicely curved low-level wind profile), and over 100 J/kg of 0-3 km MLCAPE in low-levels.  Along with over 60 kt of deep-layer wind shear, and lifting condensation level heights (LCLs, or estimated cloud bases) well below 1000 m to reduce cool outflow, this was a very favorable environment for supporting tornadoes along and just north of the outflow boundary.  Farther north of the boundary, storms became increasingly "elevated" (less surface-based regarding the instability feeding them), which would be less supportive of tornadoes.

Later that evening and night, a long-lived supercell producing multiple tornadoes emerged from the southern segment of a line of storms over far eastern TX and moved to north-central LA (see radar images below), eventually killing 2 people at Ruston, LA just before 2:00 am CDT on April 25.
The EF3 damage from this tornado at Ruston included this motel (photo below), which lost most of it's 2nd floor.  Although no one died at this location, this is a pointed reminder that shelter below ground (or at least in a small interior 1st floor room) is crucial in surviving tornadoes!

The surface map at 1:00 am CDT early morning on April 25 showed an outflow boundary that was now oriented north-northeast to south-southwest over east TX to northwest LA, with the long-lived supercell (circled "S") moving northeastward roughly along this boundary for 2-1/2 hours:
A subtle and weak warm front progressing northward over central and northern LA (thick red dashed line on surface map above), suggested by slightly backed surface winds and larger dew points by 3-4 degrees F, may have also helped in sustaining the tornadic storm.

SPC mesoanalysis images at 1:00 am CDT (below) also showed a favorable environment for supporting supercell tornadoes over west and northwest LA along and just ahead of the outflow boundary and subtle warm front:
MLCAPE (not shown) was around 1200 J/kg, 0-1 km SRH > 300 m2/s2, and low-level MLCAPE > 100 J/kg over a sizable area through which the supercell was moving.  The orientation of the boundaries apparently allowed the northeastward-moving supercell to take advantage of this supportive environment for tornadoes over a long period of time, while utilizing increased shear and convergence along/near the same boundaries.

Here's a quick look at the larger scale upper air pattern via a 500 mb forecast map from the NAM model, valid at 1:00 am CDT:










A large, intense midlevel trough was moving from TX eastward, forcing ascent over LA with the "spreading jet" pattern ahead of it inducing general upward motion and strong wind dynamics across the area where tornadoes occurred overnight.

Tragically, the tornado outbreaks in the southern U.S. on Feb 23, March 3, April 13, and now April 25 have claimed a total of 29 lives so far in 2019.  Other deaths have resulted from thunderstorm winds blowing trees down on houses and vehicles, and flash-flooding.

As severe weather season continues in 2019, know how to stay safe... watch Surviving the Storm: What Chasers Want You to Know, free on YouTube:

- Jon Davies 4/26/19

Wednesday, April 24, 2019

Landspout-type setting produces first tornadoes of 2019 for Oklahoma & Kansas on April 17



It has been a slow start to tornado season in Oklahoma (OK) and Kansas (KS), very much like last year.  Last year's first Kansas tornadoes were on May 1, and Oklahoma's were on May 2.   But this year's first tornadoes in both states (see images above) were a week ago on April 17 near Shattuck, OK (top image) and Wellington, KS (bottom image).  These appeared to be due to mainly "landspout" processes (storm updraft stretching directly over a pre-existing wind shift boundary), rather than last year's supercell tornadoes on May 1 and May 2 when plentiful low-level wind shear was present over large areas.

The surface map setting at 3:00 pm CDT on April 17 (below) showed a stationary front present as a sharp wind shift over northwest OK into the northeast Texas (TX) panhandle:





































This sharp boundary could be seen on high resolution visible satellite images at early to mid afternoon:


Radar reflectivity images from Amarillo showed a new storm developing on this boundary at 3:00 pm CDT in the northeast corner of the TX panhandle (1st image below), north of other storms farther to the south:


A radar image less than an hour later (middle image above) showed the same cell exploding with a red core.  At this time (3:52 pm CDT), a rope-like tornado (not pictured) was on the ground northeast of Canadian TX, while new cells began to develop northeastward into OK along the boundary.  The last radar image above at 4:49 pm CDT showed a supercell storm had developed in northwest OK on the boundary near Shattuck, where two tornadoes were occurring simultaneously (see the photo at the top of this post).

Although at least a couple of the storms in the northeast TX panhandle and northwest OK were supercells (storm rotation indicated on radar, but not shown here), my opinion is that the actual tornadoes were due mainly to "non-mesocyclone" or "landspout" processes, or at least that the tornadoes were a "hybrid" event (combining non-supercell and supercell processes).  This is suggested by the SPC mesoanalysis images below at 3:00 pm CDT before the tornadoes:


These graphics clearly show the stationary front wind shift boundary in the surface vorticity field (blue analysis lines and thick black dashed line on 1st image), steep low-level lapse rates from surface heating (axis of red dots, 2nd image), and no low-level wind shear (storm-relative helicity or SRH, 3rd image) over the northwest OK and the TX panhandle  where the tornadoes occurred during the following couple hours.  These are all factors that relate to landspout tornado formation.

It's also interesting that a supercell farther south that moved into west-central OK (visible on the last two panels of the radar images shown earlier) did not produce any tornadoes, although it was later tornado-warned based on radar.  This storm was within the warm sector and away from the stationary front.  But, without the sharp boundary wind shift, it had no source for low-level vorticity ("spin") as a result of the lack of SRH (low-level wind shear) over western OK during the afternoon.  (Low-level wind shear helps generate low-level rotation and mesocyclones that can give birth to supercell tornadoes.)

Here are a couple more images of one of the two tornadoes near Shattuck, OK between 4:30 and 5:00 pm CDT along the boundary (probably the tornado at right in the earlier photo):


Another tornado (a landspout) occurred in the central TX panhandle just after 5:00 pm CDT east of Amarillo, along the same boundary that extended some distance southwestward:

And, essentially the same boundary also extended into south-central KS as a pre-frontal trough, helping to generate the landspout tornado pictured earlier near Wellington around 6:40 pm CDT.

Again, this case seems to be a good example of how landspout processes can produce multiple tornadoes via strong low-level stretching directly over a sharp wind shift boundary with little immediate temperature contrast (see here for another more prolific case).

Jon Davies - 4/24/19

Wednesday, April 17, 2019

April 13-14, 2019 southern states tornado outbreak


The April 13-14 tornado outbreak across the southern states killed 3 people due to tornadoes (2 in Texas, 1 in Mississippi) and, sadly, several others died due to wind and flooding.  Tornado-wise, there were at least 10 EF2 tornadoes and 2 EF3 tornadoes on the 13th.  

The tornadoes pictured above were near Hearne, Texas (EF3) at late morning, and at Vicksburg, Mississippi at late afternoon.  Damage is also shown in east-central Texas between Weches and Alto where 2 people lost their lives in a tornado around noon-time.  Unfortunately, two children also died nearby in a vehicle from a falling tree in severe thunderstorm winds. 

The outbreak was forecast well by NWS meteorologists, the third deadly tornado outbreak across the South in 2019.  I won't do a detailed analysis here, as there was nothing particularly unusual about it.  But I did want to point out how most of the strongest tornadoes occurred with storms near and just south of the warm front that moved from east-central Texas to northern Mississippi during the day.

Severe weather forecasters know very well that the zone along and near warm fronts tends to have increased low-level shear with backed (more easterly) surface winds, so if strong warming and moistening is also occurring in that area, it becomes a favored location for supporting tornadic storms.  That can be seen on the graphics below showing warm frontal locations and the SPC effective-layer significant tornado parameter:


Even though environments well south of the warm front also looked favorable for tornadoes, the area along and just south of the warm front tended to provide the focus for most of the tornadic storms in this outbreak.

The associated upper system plowing across Texas and into the Dixie states was strong, with an intense 500 mb trough (indicated by thick red dashes):


So, along with this strong upper system, the strong surface warm front and unstable/sheared environment ahead of the surface low generated a number of tornadoes.

Even with a strong southern jet stream propelling storm systems across the southern U.S. so far this early spring, periodic intrusions of cold air from Canada from a northern branch jet stream over the Great Lakes have kept tornadoes away from Kansas and Oklahoma so far in 2019 (Kansas is off to it's 4th slowest start for tornadoes since 1990, similar to last year).  We'll see if that changes soon.

- Jon Davies  4/16/19

Friday, March 15, 2019

Tornadoes in New Mexico & Ohio Valley on March 12 & 14, 2019 with record-breaking low pressure system

The so-called "bomb cyclone" that caused hurricane force winds and record low pressure in the Plains on March 13, 2019 also brought tornadoes (see photos above) to southeast New Mexico (NM) on March 12 and to the Ohio Valley on March 14.  The tornadoes at Dexter and near Malaga NM on March 12 were the earliest EF2 tornadoes ever recorded for the state of New Mexico.

Interestingly enough, no tornadoes occurred on the day the surface low was the strongest over Colorado and Kansas (March 13, not shown).  This was because the system was so large and dynamic that it pushed associated surface fronts too far north and eastward, away from moisture and instability.  But that moisture recovered again as surface fronts slowed for severe weather on March 14th over the Ohio Valley.

This system was a good example of how warm fronts are efficient tornado producers. The surface maps below on March 12 & 14th show that the locations of several tornadic storms were near warm fronts: 



Warm fronts offer temperature gradients, increasing moisture, and enhanced low-level wind shear, which is why tornadoes seem to occur so often with storms near such boundaries. (Other tornadoes - not shown - did occur in the warm sector over Alabama during late afternoon and evening on March 14, away from boundaries.)

Note how instability and low-level wind shear combinations using forecasts of the 0-1 km energy-helicity index (EHI) from the RAP model were strong near warm fronts and tornadic storms on both days, offering good support for low-level storm rotation:



The 500mb NAM model forecasts below (roughly 18,000 ft MSL) also show how strong this system was, with a massive full-latitude midlevel trough moving out into the Plains.  A "spreading" jet stream pattern (white arrows) ahead of this large trough generated large-scale lift and ascent over the areas where daytime and evening severe weather occurred on March 12 and 14 (yellow ovals):



Thankfully, no deaths occurred from any of the tornadoes with this system.  But the Colorado blizzard associated with this powerful system claimed at least one life, and flooding in Nebraska from rapid snow melt and heavy rain caused at least one other death.

It is good to see that the week ahead will be much quieter weather-wise across the United States!

- Jon Davies 3/15/19

Monday, March 4, 2019

Many dead from huge Lee County, Alabama tornado 3/3/19



Sunday March 3, 2019 saw the largest death toll in the U.S. from a single tornado since the 2013 Moore, Oklahoma tornado.  As I write this, there are 23 deaths so far from this EF4 intensity tornado in the Beauregard/Marvyn, Alabama area, and more may be found in the next day or two.  (*** UPDATE: As of March 6, all those missing have been accounted for, and the death toll from this tornado stays at 23, with 90 people injured. ***)  With only 10 total deaths in the U.S. last year from tornadoes, the 3/3/19 event is certainly very tragic.

The tornado came from a supercell that entered southwestern Lee County in east-central Alabama around 2:00 pm CST, and the National Weather Service had both a tornado watch and a tornado warning in effect for Lee County when the tornado hit.  But with only 5-8 minutes warning lead time for the Beauregard/Marvyn area, and because this was essentially the first big tornado of a sizable outbreak and was moving fast (around 50 mph!), it probably caught some people off guard.  Also, as is so typical with southeastern U.S. tornadoes, visibility wasn't particularly good (low cloud bases, haze, and trees -- see the photos above and below), which was probably another contributing factor:

Below is a map showing the approximate path of the supercell's tornadic circulation on radar, and also two radar reflectivity images around the time of deaths in the Beauregard/Marvyn area of Lee County.  Note the large classic hook on the inset close-up radar image.



Later images showed a reflectivity "debris ball" (not shown), and correlation coefficient products from radar (not shown) indicated a distinct area of debris aloft as the tornado moved eastward toward the Georgia border.

The killer tornadic supercell occurred in a fairly classic position east of a surface low (see surface map below at 1:00 pm CST), with the storm moving roughly parallel to and just south of a stationary front.  Severe weather forecasters know this to be a rather favorable location for tornadoes.

Combinations of CAPE (instability) and wind shear were also favorable along and south of the front over east-central Alabama at early to mid-afternoon (see significant tornado parameter graphic below  from SPC mesoanalysis at 2:00 pm CST):

Computer model forecasts from the morning of 3/3/19 also did a good job of highlighting parts of central, east-central, and southeast Alabama regarding combinations of CAPE and low-level wind shear that might support tornadoes.  For example, the RAP model forecast of 0-1 km energy-helicity index (EHI) from mid-morning showed sizable EHI values for March near and ahead of the Alabama surface low at 2:00 pm CST (2000 UTC), suggesting good environmental support for supercell tornadoes:

The NAM model forecast of winds and contours at 500 mb (roughly 18,000 ft MSL) for midday on 3/3/19 showed a midlevel trough disturbance aloft (thick red dashed line below) moving toward the southern states.  A "spreading" of the jet stream pattern (white lines/arrows) ahead of this trough provided ascent over the area where the 3/3/19 outbreak took place (yellow oval).  Winds at this level were also forecast to be quite strong, approaching 70 kt, offering good support for supercells near the Alabama surface low.

Lastly, here's a RAP model 1 hour forecast sounding near Columbus, Georgia (Fort Benning, LSF) valid at 2:00 pm CST (2000 UTC), located 25-30 miles east-southeast of the tornadic supercell:

Notice the strong low-level wind shear (around 350 m2/s2 of 0-1 km SRH) and the large looping hodograph (upper left).  Winds at just 1 km above ground (roughly 3000 ft) were 50 kt/58 mph, which suggests impressive wind shear for supporting low-level rotation in storms.  Although the total CAPE wasn't terribly impressive (around 1000 J/kg), notice how much CAPE was centered around 3 km above ground.  This sizable low-level CAPE relatively close to the ground likely helped accelerate air parcels upward in a mature storm supercell updraft, assisting with tilting and stretching of horizontal vorticity from the strong low-level wind shear to support low-level rotation in the Lee County supercell.  

From all this information, sadly, it isn't a surprise that a violent and deadly tornado developed on Sunday March 3, 2019 in this setting.

====>  Consider helping Alabama tornado victims..  Check out options at:
          www.cnn.com/2019/03/04/us/iyw-help-alabama-tornado-victims/index.html

- Jon Davies  3/4/19

Monday, February 25, 2019

First deadly tornado of 2019 in Columbus MS on 2/23/19


Saturday's  EF3 tornado in Columbus, Mississippi (see above) caused the first tornado fatality of 2019 along with several injuries around 5:15 pm CST.  A tornado warning was issued for Columbus roughly 20 minutes prior to the tornado striking town, which likely helped save additional lives.

Farther north, another tornado (EF2, below) hit the west side of Burnsville in the northeast corner of Mississippi, with thankfully no injuries reported:

The setting was well-forecast on SPC outlooks (not shown), and involved an afternoon warm front over central Alabama into northeast Mississippi (see below on College of DuPage surface analysis):
An environment with larger low-level wind shear (0-1 km storm-relative helicity, or SRH, > 300 m2/s2) along and just south of the warm front coincided with sizable CAPE (> 1500 J/kg) over east-central and northeast MS (see HRRR model forecasts below).  This made for a setting supportive of strong supercell tornadoes in the area indicated:


The radar reflectivity image below shows the tornadic cells around 4:40 pm CST, about 35 minutes before Columbus was hit:

As with so many tornadoes in the Dixie states, the Columbus tornadic storm was embedded in a line of storms, which made it hard to see the tornado at times.

The larger-scale setting showed a large trough at 500 mb (roughly 18,000 ft above sea level) plowing through the central U.S.  (A cold-core system was over Kansas, but there wasn't enough CAPE for more than one or two marginal severe reports in western Missouri, not shown.)  Notice the position of the southern branch of the jet stream (thick white line and arrow), with the tornadoes occurring just north or left of that axis, similar to some other tornado episodes I documented on this blog back in early 2018:


The tornadoes also coincided with an area of large significant tornado parameter values (STP, see inset above) over east-central and northeast MS just north of the southern jet branch at 500 mb, similar to the HRRR forecast of enhanced SRH and CAPE shown earlier.

One other point of interest... Tracks/swaths of model forecast storm rotation (called updraft helicity) are a sophisticated tool from the detailed HRRR model used by many forecasters to anticipate supercell likelihood, and by association, possible tornadoes.  Shown below are the accumulated updraft helicity tracks forecast during the day on 2/23/19 by the HRRR model from the ESRL site at mid-morning, the left image showing forecast rotation tracks in the 0-2 km layer above ground, and the right image showing the same for the 2-5 km layer higher up:


Note that the lowest level (0-2 km) updraft helicity tracks are fewer, and appeared to roughly "forecast" the Columbus and Burnsville tornadic supercell tracks (red ellipses).  Although I'm not a fan of using updraft helicity forecasts as a surrogate for the possibility of tornadoes (such forecasts need to be combined with a careful assessment of environment), it is interesting that this case suggests that the lowest level 0-2 km layer product may in a loose sense be more useful in "picking out" some likelihood of tornadoes by reducing the "over-forecasting" of rotation tracks often seen in the 2-5 km layer product.  Just a subjective observation.

- Jon Davies  2/25/19